Sunday, 19 July 2015

Straight into Hot Water?

In my time talking to people about keeping fish, getting advice, offering advice, keeping fish myself, running a community about it and generally researching my ass off, there is one thing that I have noticed; 


People who are completely new to fish-keeping get some of the worst advice from magazines, the internet and other fish-keepers. 

Keeping fish can seem like a real headache for the beginner. 

Yet keeping fish is actually very easy; the headache is caused not by the amount of information out there but mainly the fact that at least two thirds of the people dispensing it haven’t got a clue what they’re talking about. 

So I thought I’d do my best to try and clear up a few misconceptions for any newbies out there –

Small tanks are best to start off with if you’re new to fish-keeping.
Nope. Smaller bodies of water are far less chemically stable than larger bodies of water. I wouldn’t recommend much less than 50 liters for newbs. You are also far less likely to seriously overstock larger tanks and if you do it will be easier to control the water chemistry and manage any problems that arise. Always get the biggest tank you can afford.

..but big tanks cost a lot to run.
Not really, no. Even a 300 liter tank will generally average out at about £3-4 per week to run. If you add food and sundries to that you’re still looking at less than £15-20 a month not including fish. The expense is in the initial set-up, not so much in the running costs.

Goldfish are easy and don't get too big
That picture, yeah, that's a goldfish - that's not an uncommon size for Carassius auratus to reach by the way. Even fancy golfish can get huge. Goldfish are Carp, carp get really big. Remember that one your nan had in that little unfiltered bowl on the side? Chances are, that if it didn't die from being in that tiny bowl, it would have grown this big.

You should definitely start off with Neon Tetras and Guppies; they are easy to keep...
Both Neons and Guppies are ridiculously line bred for colours and patterning and as such have suffered genetically over the years. Where once they were hardy fish they are now much weaker and more prone to parasites and diseases and as such are much more awkward to keep for newbs. Especially given that Neons are very susceptible to stress and Guppies breed like rabbits. Steer clear.

Planted aquariums are easy.
Yes, if you know what you are doing; between managing CO2 and lighting and selecting the correct species of plants for your tank and fish... if you are new just stick with fake ones until you get the fish-keeping aspect down. Once you get that down plants are a great way to add that extra dimension to your tank and useful for keeping your water parameters stable.

Plecos will eat algae and clean your tank.
Yeah, if you don’t feed them anything else but this is bad for them; they deserve a varied and full diet and if you give them this... they won’t eat algae. There are far better algae eating fish out there plus Plecos are poo machines so typically they will actually make your tank dirtier.

Fish will only grow as big as the tank, so don’t worry about putting that Oscar in a small tank...
This has never been shown to be true in any real sense. Yes fish may grow at a slower rate in tanks that are too small for them but they will still achieve the same final size. Make sure you look up how big the fish you want to buy will get and plan accordingly.

Yeah, don’t worry too much about cycling the tank; it’ll be good for fish in about 3 days to a week.
Yes it will, if you want dead fish. Here’s a brief on the Nitrogen cycle which, if you plan on keeping fish for any decent amount of time, you need to understand. 

When you first fill a tank up you have to cycle it to make it safe for fish. Basically speaking the tank goes through 4 stages – Ammonia spike, Nitrite spike and Nitrate spike, then stabilises. After this all you do is dilute nitrates with regular water changes.

Ammonia (NH3), or more specifically Ammonium 4+ ion (NH4+), is a toxic chemical produced by fish or in the case of a fishless cycle, decomposing organic matter or addition of ammonia to the tank water. In the first stage ammonia will build up in the tank as bacterial cultures that break down NH3 grow in the filter. In stage 2 there will be a Nitrite (NO2) spike as the bacteria convert Ammonium into Nitrite. Finally Nitrite ‘eating’ bacteria will convert NO2 into Nitrate (NO3). 

Of all the three aquarium chemicals Nitrate is the least harmful to fish but is still toxic in high enough amounts – that’s what you’re doing when you conduct a water change – diluting the Nitrates.

How long does the nitrogen cycle take?  
Not 3 days, put it that way. The process has a number of variables, not limited to; amount of ammonia produced during the cycling period, efficiency of biological filtration, whether live rocks or plants are used during the process2.

The best way to check how your cycle is going is to get yourself a test kit that measures ammonia as well as NO2 and 3 and test every other day until the tank stabilises and the only measurement is Nitrates. Only then should you introduce fish. There is no way to time a cycle, or even estimate a time scale - Be patient.

Now some snippets of good advice to get you started;


Don’t shy away from big water changes.

Many people will advise 10-20% changes but realistically this isn’t enough. Many tanks will survive on this water change volume but fish love new water; it also works to increase their tolerance for your tap water over time. Once a filter is established you can change out at least 50-60% happily, if not more. I’ve met people who do 70-80% every week. Arguably one of the best ways for newbies to get the hang of good tank husbandry is to keep to a 7 day schedule – 50% every Friday (or whenever us convenient for you) and do regular tank maintenance like siphoning waste and cleaning glass every few days in-between the main WC. Some change water every 2 weeks but do higher volumes, I’ve even met some who do it once a month but change the best part of 90%. For the beginner however, a weekly schedule is far easier to get the hang of and it far less likely to cause issues.

Avoid Overstocking.

Keeping fish is about balance – you are creating a mini ecosystem that your fishes will live in. One problem is over-stocking; Stocking levels used to be calculated by surface area but this was largely replaced by water volume with the advent of filters. Before filters were in wide use the exchange of gases (carbon dioxide and oxygen) in the aquarium was limited by the water’s surface area1, but this is not the case now thanks to modern filtration. The effects of overstocking are multiple but the main problem is waste – more fish = more waste products than your filtration can handle. Next to this fish can become stressed in cramped conditions and many species can become aggressive or reclusive.  Stressed fish in poor quality water is a perfect recipe for disease and illness. Here is a very comprehensive stocking calculator courtesy of AqAdvisor (http://aqadvisor.com/)

Make sure shoaling fish have shoals.

Making sure you have the right amount of a given species of fish is important. Many smaller species and indeed some big ones too are shoaling fish. They like to be together in groups. Commonly bought shoaling fish for beginners are things like the fated Guppies and Neons and other small Characins and Cyprinids like Harlequin Rasboras, Tetras and Danios and the smallest catfish – the Corydoras. All these fish like to be in groups of at least 6 individuals; generally the more the better. If they do not have groups to be a part of many can become reclusive, even aggressive and more prone to stress and in turn, diseases. 


Treating disease and illness

It happens to the best of fish-keepers and it will happen to you. Probably the leading cause of disease is addition of new fish/plants or other aquatic animals. There are far too many diseases to list here but it's not all doom and gloom don't worry. Thanks to modern science there are a host of very effective treatments on the market that will take care of your fish when they get ill. There is one disease that is so common that scientists conclude that a great deal of fish carry it and such is worth mentioning. The disease is Ich (White Spot). There are a host of "theories" around treating this common disease but addition of salt and increase of heat in your aquarium is NOT advised, no matter what people tell you. Get some dedicated medicines for your fish, they have long shelf lives so get them before you need them. 

Heat, light and filtration

All tropical fish need heat and filtration at least, the lights are more for your viewing pleasure and for any live plants you might keep. Tropical water temperatures are between 23-27 degrees Celsius. If the fish are tropical they will need water temperatures within this range. Though all fish vary slightly in their specific temperature requirements a good average temperature for most common tropical fish is 24-25.Filtration should be as strong as you can get, you want a filter that will do 4 x the tank volume every hour ideally. So a 60 liter tank you'll need a 240 L/ph filter. Don't skimp on your filtration, it is the most important thing in your tank.  

Research the fish you plan to keep

You would have thought this would go without saying but it doesn’t, sadly. You need to know exactly what’s going into your tank, what they need to eat, what other fish they will mix with, if they like lots of cover and subdued lighting or plenty of room to swim around and what water parameters they require. Though most farmed hobby fish are usually quite tolerant of various tank conditions you should always try to emulate their natural environments as best you can if you want to see the best your fishes have to offer.

Here are a few of links that contain good information:

Fishbase
Seriously Fish
Practical Fishkeeping
Think Fish

Someone once told me when I was starting out that you don't keep fish, you keep water. The fish will look after themselves if you give them the right environment. 


Thankfully, giving them the right environment has never been easier.

 ~

1 http://www.thinkfish.co.uk/article/stocking-levels-for-tropical-aquarium-fish
2 http://www.liveaquaria.com/PIC/article.cfm?aid=74

Dispelling "Common" Misconceptions

I feel like I need to do this every week; 
dispel the myth about "Common Plecos". 
To put it bluntly, 
THERE IS NO SUCH FISH!


"Common Pleco" is an inaccurate and generic term given to poorly identified fishes of the genus Loricariidae and actually covers at least four different speciesPterygoplichthys pardalis, Pterygoplichthys multiradiatus, Hypostomus plecostomus and Hypotomus punctatus. 

I've even seen Ptergoplichthys gibbiceps marked up as a 'Common Pleco' by some less knowledgeable aquarium shops.

Well, why is regarding every Pleco as a "Common Pleco" a problem?

Firstly, it’s lazy fish keeping. 
Let’s be honest here, you can’t even be bothered to find out what your fish is? You must have noticed it looked different from other types of fish, even other types of Pleco.  

Secondly, though they are similar in many ways, in other ways they are quite different. Take size for instance, an important consideration when choosing fish...
P. Gibbiceps and P. Multiradiatus can reach 45(18") and 50 cm(20") respectively. While P. Pardalis, H. Plecostomus and H. Punctatus will only reach 35(14"), 30(12") and 26cm(10") respectively. So immediately there is a size difference of at least 25cm(10") between the bigger specimens and the smallest ones; that’s a lot.

Go and measure that, I’ll wait...

Yeah, see that? 
25cm is a quarter of a meter(best part of a foot). That’s the difference between requiring only a 100L(26gal) tank and needing a tank four times that volume with filtration to match for a fully grown fish and don't believe any of the rubbish like "it'll only get as big as the tank". 

Fish are living creatures and when you take one home you have a moral responsibly to its long term care
If you don’t think you do, then you shouldn’t be keeping fish. 

You need to consider the requirements of any fish you keep but more so with big fishes or fish that can get big. How are you going to plan for the long term care of a fish when you don’t know what it is?

Many simply say that when if it gets too big for them or they can't look after it properly they'll just ship it out to their local aquarium shop or someone with a bigger tank.Well, I've got news for you buddy; not every shop wants your unwanted Pleco. In fact many aquarium shops are inundated with unwanted fish, what makes you think they'll take yours? So you'll go to some dealer online that'll take it off your hands. That's one route, but do you know anything about this dealer? How do you know it won't go from your tank into another unsuitable tank or if it will be properly looked after by this person? So now you're stuck with this fish that could grow to half a meter and you haven't the space nor the money for a big aquarium. 

So you see, knowing what catfish you have just brought home is important. These aren't 2 week wonders either, they're not like Guppies and Neons, these fish can live for 20 years. 

~

Now I appreciate that the fact you refer to your Loricarid (a fish of the the Genus Loricariidae) as a "sucker mouth catfish", a "common pleco" or some other imprecise general name, is because that's what was written on the tank at the store - and they must know what they're talking about, right? 

The genus Loricariidae contains the most species of any family of Catfish; nearly 700 different species have been scientifically recognised - even more if we including those that still reside solely under L-number classifications, which currently stretch from L001 (Ptergoplichthys Joselimaianus) to L600 (Pseudacanthicus Leopardus). No doubt new species will be added as time progresses.

That's a hell of a lot of different species.

In fact, many fish are frequently misidentified at aquarium shops, particularly catfish. The reason is because they deal with a lot of different fish and sometimes they come into the shop misidentified as well. With stock turning over and a busy shop to run, not to mention maintaining 40+ holding tanks both tropical fresh, cold and marine, sometimes those in the know get it wrong too. 



So it's on you then, isn't it.

I don't really know another way to say this;
It's absolutely your job to know what's in your tank, what it needs, how big it will get and if you can offer it the long term care that it requires, no, that it DESERVES. 

Which means it's on you to know what type of Pleco you've got stuck to your aquarium glass.

Thankfully, I've done at last some of the leg work for you; useful Links to accurately identify your misidentified "Common" Pleco:

Wikipedia - List of Common Aquarium Fishes, it's as good a place to start as any:

Seriously Fish - Knowledge Base (Siluriformes), more extensive than Wikipedia, not as indepth as Planet Catfish.

Planet Catfish - Cat-eLog, requires more patience but it's probably the most comprehensive list on the net.